Critical Reading as a Book Blogger & How It’s Fun {Blog Discussion}

The book community generally has a very positive outlook and energy when talking about books, which is fantastic! However, if, like me, you were part of the early Booktube-era you can remember a time when negative reviews or critiques weren’t really a thing, or if they were they were pretty rare. I think though we can all agree, critique and critical thinking about the works we consume does matter and can expand our ideas in how we reflect on literature.

As time has passed, naturally with the more I blog, read, review books, or talk about them, I’m finding particular patterns or styles, expressions, elements of storytelling and engaging with those ideas in a more analytical fashion.

This will probably be a post I expand on in some later date, but I thought it was about time I discussed the idea of “critical reading” on my blog because its something that’s been on my mind for a couple years now.

Now “Reading Critically” isn’t exactly equated to ratings, but that can go hand-in-hand in cases. However, for me I choose to look at it as actively reflecting on the execution of many elements the book presents: the author’s writing style or use of language, the themes being presented, my own interpretations and how it’s being lent to the reading experience, character construction, effective use of page-time, plotting, among many other factors that likely be their own separate post.

For readers who are new to the book community or reading for general enjoyment looking to make entertaining content (like some of booktok right now) a trend I’ve noticed on my fyp is that people rate their a lot of books pretty highly which makes sense, it’s more accessible to people who want to get into reading, that’s great ― however, it’s also a platform in which the more popular, quick content needs to be broken down much faster which means…not too much time to delve into a lot of thoughts.

Even though I’m still the kind of reader who reads for enjoyment because these stories are pure escapism, joy and overall fun to read, there are moments that the critical thinking light goes on and I can’t escape it. This leads to me flying through the book with a more in-depth look at the author’s use of prose, worldbuilding, dialogue, or character voice, etc. examining if it’s effective in telling the story, from my perspective. And you know what, I find it incredibly rewarding!

When analyzing a book of course we come into it with different perspectives or ideas on what we hope the book will be or achieve. However, I think there’s many questions we can consider when trying to read more critically, but here’s a few to get started: is the world or atmosphere effectively built in the story? does the dialogue feel realistic or make sense with the character? Does the plot progress in a realistic fashion with what the author has established?

My reading experience honestly becomes more memorable because I’m engaging with the author’s work more seriously and taking the ideas they are presenting with more construction, like with my recent review of This Poison Heart for instance. The atmosphere and character journey of Bri was my favorite part, however the rating was less than I expected & yet the reading experience itself was fun for me not only because it was my first book I’d read by Kalynn Bayron, but also taking away from the story this element of self-discovery that was effectively explored through Bri’s inheritance of her birth family’s estate. Another one of my favorite examples is my critical essay on Heartstopper (do give it a read, if you’d like a more detailed look at how I present my analysis πŸ’•)

For me I also approach reading critically as absorbing the ideas, themes and concepts the author has presented and taking them seriously. Even if the review may not be “glowing,” I find joy in the fact I’m taking what they say very thoughtfully, challenging me to see how effective they are presenting these elements in the story.

While this discussion can probably go on for thousands of words more, I’ll leave it here saying that in the process of writing this discussion, I’ve also thought about revisiting more “popular” YA Books like Six Of Crows for example and delving into more criticism, from a new angle or perspective. If there’s any other popular or well-known Young Adult books you’d like me to consider for more in-depth analysis please, let me know below!

Are you a Critical Reader? What do you look for or pay attention to when reviewing? If you’ve been reading or blogging for a while, have you seen you ratings or reviewing perspective change?


18 thoughts on “Critical Reading as a Book Blogger & How It’s Fun {Blog Discussion}

  1. What an interesting topic! I feel like I follow people who don’t mind writing less-than-stellar reviews which is nice because I want to know the good and the bad. I also want to share my opinion with others even if it is unpopular. I feel like Goodreads is full of reviews that feel fake but that could just be me lol.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. thank you for reading joanna! 😌✨ that’s good, its nice to have a range of differing opinions & true, I feel like I do too, sometimes my blog absences make me think I sometimes miss them in my feed though 😭 Yes GR can be both good & bad…Sometimes goodreads can also betray me because I see such a high rating for a frankly mediocre book 😫

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I find that often I can’t turn my critical reading skills off! I know some people think that reading critically ruins the fun, but, to me, thinking about what I’m reading often IS the fun! Of course, I don’t actively analyze every book like I’m going to write a thesis on it. And I definitely enjoy a lot of stories just to relax, and might even try not to think too hard about them (because that could ruin it once I start seeing all the plot holes or whatever). But, on the whole, I like reading critically and I like reading reviews that do the same!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m the same exact way! Often times I don’t intentionally mean to enter a book with a critical eye, it just happens but its also true that it’s also part of the fun! Same here, though for some reason I often find it tough to find those reviews, thanks for reading Krysta! πŸ’•

      Liked by 1 person

  3. This is a really interesting discussion and it gets me thinking about how we talk about books. I think critically reading can be very useful and almost encourages us, as readers, to be active participants whilst reading. Instead of just letting it pass us by? If that makes sense.
    Sometimes I have felt like I am too positive a reviewer and never have anything new to add to conversations around the book, but other times I struggle to articulate why things didn’t work for me. (I have a lot of doubts about my skills as a reviewer πŸ˜‚)
    But saying that, I think I have become more critical as I’ve got older, hopefully due to being aware of the content I am reading and knowing what I want. I hope I have also grown into pinpointing what I liked and didn’t like in books. I think taking the approach of critically reading would have encouraged me to have this growth quicker and delve into my thoughts past the surface level. It would open more discussions in a good way so I think there are a lot of positive to critically reading. Loved this post πŸ’—

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m so sorry for this late reply Sophie!! πŸ˜…πŸ’• I love that idea and that’s exactly what I’ve given more thought to as I continue reading / reviewing, I want to engage with the author’s work in a different way and not let it pass especially if I feel I have a strong opinion about it. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with positive reviews (especially yours 😍) & it’s also something that comes with time (which is exactly what happened to me), so don’t feel like its something to rush into. In my opinion, I think its best to gravitate towards that mind set at your own pace because its more about figuring out what each of us personally do or don’t enjoy about books, which is all very different for each of us. I do hope there’s more conversation around this because its not meant to be a bad thing, like you’ve also mentioned. Thanks as always for your truly wonderful comments 😭❣

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Great post! This is, by far, how I approach reviewing a book. I can’t turn it off and I find myself describing what I think about the worldbuilding or what themes I think are present. There’s no “wrong” way to approach reviewing a book and everyone should do what makes them happy. But because my brain works more analytically I do find I enjoy those types of reviews more than one that’s a paragraph summary of one’s overall emotional reaction to it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m so glad you agree Celeste, that’s exactly how I approach reading certain books, with a lot of those ideas & questions forming as the story continues. Same here, those types of reviews always stand out to me more because its so interesting to see a more analytical approach to someone’s opinion. Thank you so much for reading!! πŸ˜πŸ“š

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I remember the early Booktube-era and definitely agree they were pretty rare to see. I think personally I’ve also changed a lot as a reviewer, and not necessarily because I started blogging as a high school freshman versus blogging as a young adult who graduated from college in recent years (though that for sure plays a part, because I start to know what works for me, what doesn’t, etc.). Back then, most of my reviews were more… emotional and less critical and now I’m still somewhat emotional, but I think I also examine books a lot deeper and notice the author’s intent, which sometimes change what I would normally rate the book.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So perfectly said! I think overtime we begin to see what works or doesn’t work for us as we get into more books. Diving deeper into the author’s intent or execution of their story is something I’ve recently started thinking about too, I agree it also changes my rating sometimes but that adds something to the experience too I think. Thanks for the wonderful comment Sophia 😍

      Liked by 1 person

  6. This is a great discussion post! I do think that a lot of the time we can be passive in the books we read – which isn’t a bad thing, but it’s good to be critical and analytical too. I usually focus on atmosphere and pacing and character development.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think about this a lot, especially with so many new releases that get hyped up, its always more rewarding to dive deeper into the story. I love focusing those parts of stories also, especially when it comes to characters. thank you for the lovely comment Saima! 😍

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I feel like I’m a post-critical reader. Like I think about the plot, characters, and writing after I’m done with the book. While I’m reading I just try to enjoy the book, since that’s why I’m reading it in the first place. However, I do find myself being critical when I see spelling or punctuation errors, haha. This was a great topic to discuss!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s